CD's
Old
Electric Wort Boiler
c.d. pritchard
rev. 0 4/23/97 Brief update/ link to new boiler, 2/01
Update:
Since I wanted to do 10 gal. batches,
I now use a hacked SS Sankey keg with a single 4500 watt element.
Details are on the New Wort Boiler Page.
Credit:
This boiler is based on one developed
by Ken Schwartz. Ken did all of the hard work developing the boiler
proper. THANKS Ken! His web page, the Plastic
Electric Brewery, is a "must see".
Why:
I detest having to have propane cylinders
refilled- it's both a hassle and expensive. The electrically "fired" boiler
allows for safe indoor brewing. Using the electric boiler indoors is much
safer than using a propane burner indoors. (I'd NEVER use a cooker
intended for use outdoors inside my home!)
Advantages:
-
No more propane to hassle with!
-
The stirrer reduces concerns about scorching
of the wort by the heating elements.
-
With the immersion chiller, the stirrer moves
the hot wort over the coils of the chiller and greatly speeds cooling.
-
The chiller, with it's integral lid, helps
keep junk out of the boiler during cooling. This aids greatly in keeping
the wort sanitary.
-
It's very cheap to boil water and wort with
electricity- less than 25 cents where I live!
-
Automated boiling is possible. A computer
based controller is in the works. It will help eliminate boilovers and
adjust the boiling rate to yeild the target volume of wort.
Cautions:
-
Electricity can be dangerous. Don't attempt
this project if your are not comfortable working with electricity. Ground
all exposed metal parts and use a GFCI on each 120 VAC circuit!
-
Boiling wort is hot and will burn you.
-
Use a HDPE (hgh density polyethylene) pail
with a marked wall thickness rating of "NRC 090".
-
The HDPE is not rated for use at boiling temperature.
It does get a bit soft, but still works well.
-
Use lead free solder and use it sparingly.
Clean the flux residue after soldering.
-
Run a couple of acidified water boils before
using the boiler with a wort. I used lactic acid to drop the pH to ~4.
Here's a drawingof
the boiler:
The Pail:
The pail is labeled "Plastican" and "NRC
090". The later is, I think, a thickness rating. Don't use the ones labeled
"NRC 070" as they may not be strong enough. The pail is advertised as 6.5
gallons but actually holds a tad more than 7 gallons when filled to the
brim.
I reinforced the walls of the pail with
a layer of aluminum flashing covered by a wrapped layer of 1/2" mesh hardware
cloth. The edges of the cloth were fastened together with twisted pieces
of steel wire. Holes were cut to allow the heating elements and wort outlet
fitting to protrude. I really don't think this reinforcement is necessary.
Ken doesn't use any and reports no problems but this boiler is insulated
and the insulation means the pail walls will be at a higher temperature
than an uninsulated pail. Anyhow, it was cheap, easy to do and adds a bit
of piece of mind.
The lower portion of the boiler (up to
just below where the wood stirrer blocks fasten) was insulated with 2 layers
of aluminum faced "bubble wrap" insulation. All edges were sealed with
aluminum faced tape (NOT duct tape!) to avoid heat loss via convection
currents. The outside of the aluminum is barely warm to the touch when
boiling.
Pail Extensions:
The pail extensions provide a bit of added
volume for containing the foam resulting from boiling all-grain derived
worts. If you only brew with extracts, skip making extensions. The extensions
were cut from the upper parts of two "spare" 5 gal. pails. Another strip
of plastic liberated from the top of one of the pails is wrapped around
the lower portion of the lower extension. This takes up some of the slop
between the extension and the boiler proper. I first tried roughening all
mating surfaces with fresh 100 grit sandpaper, cleaning with acetone, smearing
all mating surfaces with silicone and jamming the extension/spacer into
the top of the pail. It didn't bond well- polyethylene is notorious for
its immunity to adhesives. The "final" solution is was to wrap the spacer
with thick clear polyethylene tape so that a tight fit is ensured. The
upper extension is a bit shallower than the lower extension- part of it's
reinforcing rim was removed to increase it's diameter a bit. Again, polyethylene
tape was applied as a spacer to ensure tight fit. The fit of the extensions,
although tight at room temp., loosened a bit when the boiler was brought
up to operating temperature. To make the joints secure, more polyethylene
tape was wrapped around the joints. I don't particularly like using tape,
but, it sure is handy, remains in place well and doesn't affect the brew.
Heaters:
Here's a detail of how to mount the heaters:
I used two Chromalox brand 1500 W, 120
VAC rated low watt density type hot water heater elements (model # SGW-2157L).
Do not use conventional elements- they have too high of a power density
and, it's said, will scorch the wort. The heaters have a straight (not
pipe thread) 1" threaded end and are furnished with a black rubber washer
for mounting. Cut a hole for each element in the sides of the pail. Position
the lower hole so that the heating element is about 1/2 to 3/4" above the
bottom of the pail. The other is positioned so that the element clears
the lower element by 1/4-1/2". I used the lower portion of one of the pails
I cut the extension from to test-mount the elements. Make the edges of
the holes very smooth. Rough edges or cuts can act as stress risers and
lead to rupture of the boiler. This would not be a good thing. I used a
hole saw (usually used for installing door latches and locks) which was
slightly under-sized and enlarged the hole to size with a 1/2 round fine
cut file. The edges of the holes were then finished with 280 grit then
400 grit sandpaper. The heaters are fitted with a homemade grounding fitting
and the washer, poked through the hole in the pail then secured with a
copper nut. The nut was cut from the 1" NPT female end of a copper fitting.
Don't scrimp here- there are electrical lock nuts which look good size-wise
but the ones I've seen are made of galvanized steel or an unknown plastic.
I would trust either of these materials... The ground washer has a protruding
lug for attaching a grounding conductor and was made from some 3/4" Cu
pipe that was slit, opened, pounded flat and cut to shape.
Stirrer:
Here's a drawing of the stirrer:
I was kinda concerned about stratification
of the wort and poor circulation, and possible scorching so I came up with
the idea of stuffing a stirrer into the boiler. It works great and also
greatly speeds cooling of the wort with and immersion chiller after boiling.
6 gallons can be cooled to 68 degF with 64 degF tap water in only 15 minutes.
The blade of the stirrer is made from two
pieces of 3/4" copper rigid tubing. The pieces were slit longitudinally
down the centerline, opened up a bit and formed into the "S" shape indicated
on the drawing. The "S" shape is very efficient and fairly easy to form.
A riveted and soldered lap joint was used to fasten the two pieces together.
The stirrer shaft was constructed from 1/2" rigid copper tubing. A coupling
was soldered to the end of the blade and a slot was cut in the lower end
of the shaft/coupling to accept the top of the stirrer blade. The coupling
acts as a bit of reinforcement for the joint. Finally, the shaft was soldered
to the blade.
The top of the shaft goes through a coupling
that's soldered to a 1/8" thick brass mounting plate. The coupling serves
as a bearing for the shaft. The plate is fastened to the hardwood stirrer
support with 4 screws. The protruding shaft is fitted with yet another
coupling which acts as thrust bearing to hold up the stirrer. It has 6
longitudinal kerfs sawn about 1/2 way through the length of the coupling.
A hose clamp is fitted over the kerfs and tighten to secure the coupling
to the shaft. Atop the end of the shaft is a drive coupling made from a
1/2" copper end cap. It is also kerfed and gets a hose clamp to secure
it to the shaft. A hole was drilled into the top of the cap to accept a
piece of brass whose top was machined to fit the gearmotor's 1/8" dia.
shaft. A locking screw secures the brass coupler to the gearmotor. The
bearing surfaces were smeared with a bit high temp. grease. Don't overdo
the greasing- grease in your brew is not good.
The gearmotor is made by Rowe and is speced
70 RPM at 12 VDC and 200 mA. Surplus Center (800-488-3407) carries them
as item # 5-1162 for $5.95. I drive it with the same variable voltage DC
power supply I use for my RIMS pump, however, a fixed 12 VDC power supply
should work fine. I run the stirrer at 9 volts (about 60 RPM) during the
boil and then run it full-speed after the wort temp. drops to around 100
degF.
Chiller and Lid
Here's a drawing of the chiller and lid:
I really like this setup over the old
chiller I used with the retired propane fired boiler since it's easy to
install and the wort is well sealed from exterior contaminates.
The drawing gives most of the details.
The tubing is 3/8" OD refrigeration type. The length of the tubing used
for the coil is perhaps a bit too long, but, I'm blessed with pretty high
water pressure at the tap, hence the extra length doesn't hurt (wide open,
the flow is about 2 GPM). The coils are spot-soldered to the riser tube
and a support 1/4" dia. copper tubing support (Hint: use a twist of copper
wire to temporally secure the support to each coil and remove them after
soldering.)made from 1/4" copper tubing located 180 degs. The end of the
1/4" dia. support was flattened and bent to fit the surface of the bottom
coil then soldered to it. A small drain hole was made in the bottom of
is tube.
During the boil, the chiller and lid are
NOT installed in the boiler! About 10 minutes before I terminate the boil,
I remove the stirrer assembly, install the chiller/lid, then put the stirrer
assembly back on top. The lid is raised about 1/4" with some wood blocks
to minimize the chance of boil-over. A couple of minutes prior to "flame-out",
the power to the heaters is throttled, the blocks removed and the lid is
secured to the boiler.
Manifold and Outlet
Fittings
Here's a drawing of the outlet fitting:
The manifold is made from the stainless
steel sheath liberated from hose intended for connecting plumbing fixtures.
I really like this stuff! The sheathing is obtained by pulling out the
inner rubberish liner. I used a piece about 2' long. The stuff works really
well with the whole hops I use. The whole hops act as a filer bed for removal
of the hot break and (I think) a big part of the cold break. It allows
a run-off of 1/4 to 1/2 GPM. The sheathing is put over the ends of the
outlet tee and covered with a couple of pieces of copper fabricated from
some 3/8" tubing. The pieces of copper are secured with a wrap of copper
wire. Here's a drawing of the thing:
The exit fitting is assembled as shown
on the drawings. I found it necessary to deepen (using a triangular file)
the threads a bit on the male adapter so that the "nut" could be tighten
sufficiently.
The sight gauge is calibrated by filling
the pail with water from a 2 quart container. (Hint- mark the PEX sight
gauge by scoring with a knife then applying and quickly rubbing off a permanent
marker.) Although not shown on the drawing, there's another, electronic
type level transducer which will be hooked to a control computer in the
future. The level transducer is detailed here.
Power and Wiring
All 120 VAC boiler wiring is 3 conductor,
14 AWG, type SJT flexible cord. The elements will draw over 10 amps so,
ensure you made very good connections. For connection to the heater terminals,
I twisted and bent the end of the wires, fluxed them, then soldered. One
heater is powered via a GFCI protected receptacle close to the boiler while
the other element receives power from another GFCI protected receptacle
which is on a different branch circuit via a 25', 12 AWG extension cord.
Make sure no other big loads will be on the circuit at the same time you're
powering the heating elements or you may trip the circuit breaker.
Temperature Sensing
I use a Radio Shack # 271-110A 10k Ohms
@ 25 degC thermistor. It's wired using some Teflon insulated 24 AWG wiring
and installed in a 1/4" OD copper tube. The thermistor protrudes 1/8" from
the end of the tubing and the space between the tube and the thermistor/wiring
is filled well with silicone. Currently, I just have the thing connected
to a Ohmmeter and look up the temp. on a temp. vs. resistance table I derived
(using a curve fitting program and a spreadsheet) from the data on the
back of the thermistor packaging.
Controller
A computer based boiler controller is
in the works. It'll control the initial propensity of an unwatched wort
to boil over and will control the boil to give the correct final volume.
Currently, a typical light switch (rated 15 A @ 125 VAC) controls one element
while the other element is controlled via a kitchen range surface element
control. These gizmos are basically timers- they don't modulate the voltage
as would a dimmer. Typically, both elements are at full power during the
boost to boiling. During the boil, one is full on and the other is set
to about about 30% of full power.
Return to CD's page
Comments, Questions, ect...
If you've questions or suggestions I'd
really like to hear them! Please email me here: cdp@chattanooga.net
Legal Mumbo-Jumbo:
This thing works well for
me- YMMV. Electricity can be dangerous. Don't even attempt this project
if you're not completely comfortable with it! The design and all info are
free if you use them for your making your own boiler. If you make 'em for
profit and I want a cut of the action.
Last Modified: April 23,
1997